| Year | Theme | Prize | Captain | Captain Prize |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1950 | Oriental Dancers | 6 | Foster McKoskey | - |
| 1951 | Alaskan Sunset | 4 | Foster McKoskey | - |
| 1952 | Land of the Midnight Sun | 3 | Jack Wichert | - |
| 1953 | King Mumus and His Court Jesters | - | Joe Walters | - |
| 1954 | African Voodoo Warriors | 1 | Joe Walters | - |
| 1955 | Calypso Fantasy | 1 | Joe Walters | - |
| 1956 | Roman Holiday | 1 | Joe Walters | - |
| 1957 | Persian Market | 1 | Joe Walters | - |
| 1958 | Navajo Medicine Men | 4 | Joe Walters | - |
| 1959 | South Pacific | 3 | Joe Walters | - |
| 1960 | Javanese Temple Dancers | 1 | Joe Walters | 1 |
| 1961 | Jungle Madness | 1 | Joe Walters | 1 |
| 1962 | Mardi Gras Sud Americano | 5 | Joe Walters | - |
| 1963 | Land of the Pharoahs | 3 | Joe Walters | - |
| 1964 | Polka Festival | 9 | Joe Walters | - |
| 1965 | Demetrius and The Gladiators | 4 | Joe Walters | - |
| 1966 | The Aztecs | 1 | Joe Walters | - |
| 1967 | Siam | 3 | Joe Walters | 3 |
| 1968 | Witch's Sabbath | 3 | Joe Walters | 1 |
| 1969 | The Black Watch | 2 | Joe Walters | - |
| 1970 | Minstrels | 16 | Joe Walters | - |
| 1971 | Watusi | 6 | Joe Walters | 4 |
| 1972 | Latin Fantasy | 3 | Joe Walters | 1 |
| 1973 | Showtime On Broad Street | 7 | Joe Walters | - |
| 1974 | Gypsy Caravan | 13 | Bud Krajicek | - |
| 1975 | Cult of the Cobra | 4 | Bud Krajicek | - |
| 1976 | Salute to Sousa | 10 | Bill Keller, Jr. | - |
| 1977 | Polska | 10 | Bill Keller, Jr. | - |
| 1978 | Circus Fantasia | 9 | Bill Keller, Jr. | - |
| 1979 | Disco Fever | 8 | Bill Keller, Jr. | - |
| 1980 | World of the Unknown | 2 | Bill Keller, Jr. | 1 |
| 1981 | In the Shadows of Hades | 2 | Bill Keller, Jr. | 3 |
| 1982 | Odyssey | 2 | Bill Keller, Jr. | 2 |
| 1983 | The Conquest | 10 | Bill Keller, Jr. | - |
| 1984 | Scotland the Brave | 2 | Bill Keller, Jr. | - |
| 1985 | Wooden Soldiers on Parade | 6 | Bill Keller, Jr. | - |
| 1986 | Jitterbugs | 4 | Bill Keller, Jr. | - |
| 1987 | Miami Slice | 9 | Bill Keller, Jr. | - |
| 1988 | Intermission At the Drive-In | 4 | Bill Keller, Jr. | - |
| 1989 | Happy Hour | 4 | Fred Keller | - |
| 1990 | For Amusement Only | 11 | Fred Keller | - |
| 1991 | A Change in the Weather | 7 | Fred Keller | - |
| 1992 | South of the Border | 4 | Fred Keller | - |
| 1993 | Nonsense on the Nile | 2 | Fred Keller | 1 |
| 1994 | How the West Was Fun | 4 | Fred Keller | 3 |
| 1995 | Into The Woods | 2 | Fred Keller | 1 |
| 1996 | India - The Ultimate Adventure | 3 | Fred Keller | 2 |
| 1997 | Primal Rage | 5 | Fred Keller | 3 |
| 1998 | Alien Encounter | 1 | Fred Keller | 2 |
| 1999 | Mega-City - The Next Generation | 2 | Fred Keller | 2 |
| 2000 | The Isle of Dr. Moreau | 1 | Fred Keller | 2 |
| 2001 | Atlantis: The Lost Continent | 1 | Fred Keller | 2 |
| 2002 | Arctic Adventure | 3 | Fred Keller | - |
| 2003 | Carnivale of the Animals | 2 | Fred Keller | 2 |
| 2004 | Speakeasy | 6 | Fred Keller | - |
| 2005 | The Elements | 2 | Fred Keller | 1 |
| 2006 | Quest for Shangri-La | 5 | Joe Gallagher | - |
| 2007 | Merlin's Magical Knights of Avalon | 4 | Joe Gallagher | 3 |
| 2008 | Creepy Carnival | 3 | Joe Gallagher | 4 |
| 2009 | Animals of the Rainforest | 6 | Joe Gallagher | 4 |
| 2010 | Playtime | 4 | Joe Gallagher | - |
| 2011 | Clash of the Titans | 1 | Joe Gallagher | 1 |
| 2012 | Ancient Egypt: Rise of the Mummies | 3 | John Lynch, Jr. | 2 |